Some people are dog people, and others are firm cat lovers. You can’t deny that cats can be adorable when they want to be. As cats get older, they may not be as active as they once were. That’s where the best catnip toys can help.
In this guide, we will highlight three of the best cat toys with catnip and go over their details and what people had to say about them. At the end of this guide, we will give you our ultimate recommendation.
MaximumVenture is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. This is an affiliate program which means we earn fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. However, this will not increase the prices you pay for products.
Best Cat Nip Toys
Winner: SmartyKat Catnip Toys
The SmartyKat Catnip Toys have several different options that you can choose from.
You can opt for the catnip mice 6 pack, the catnip flyer 2 pack, CatnipStix 3 pack, Fish Flop, and Skitter Critters.
For this mini-review, we are going to look at the Mice 6 Pack.
These adorable little mice are approximately four inches long (body measures two inches, tail measures approximately two inches) that are the perfect size for cats to bat around and play with. 
These cat toys are spiked with potent, organic catnip that will give your feline friend a nice boost of energy. When the effects of the catnip wear off, your cat will be relaxed and mellow. Notable Features of the SmartyKat Catnip Toys include:
Because these mice feature excellent craftsmanship, your kitty won’t be able to tear it open and remove the fiberfill. With that said, this also means that you cannot refill them once the catnip loses its potency.
The overwhelming majority of consumers who purchased these toys for their cats had excellent things to say. Some of these glowing reviews touched on how responsive their kitties were to the catnip.
Several cat owners had elderly cats, and they wanted to give them a little pick-me-up, and it worked. One customer even said that they purchased these toys for Christmas and wrapped them under the tree. They went on to say that their kitty found the toys and unwrapped them by themselves.
With that said, there were a small number of reviews from customers who had some problems with the product. One of the main concerns people had was how easily their cats could tear the mice apart.
One said there were plastic bags inside the toy instead of fiberfill, as indicated on the product description. Therefore they threw the toys out because they were afraid of them becoming a choking hazard.
Runner Up: Yeowww! Yellow Banana Catnip Toy
The Yeowww! Yellow Banana Catnip Toy is a fun little toy that measures seven inches long and three inches wide, making it the perfect size for cats to wrestle, kick, and even toss when playing with it.
The fabric used outside the toy is made from textured cotton twill, making the toy incredibly durable, even for the most vicious of hunters.
Don’t be surprised if your cat starts carrying it around with them! The Yellow Banana toy is filled only with 100% high-quality, organic catnip.
The Yellow Banana toy is filled only with 100% high-quality, organic catnip. Although the catnip will lose it?s potency over time, you can help prolong its potency by sticking the toy in the freezer until you’d like to give it to your cat. Notable Features of the Yeowww! Yellow Banana Catnip Toy includes:
The Yeowww! Yellow Banana Catnip Toy is a popular catnip toy among customers. Customers rave about how quickly their cat took to the toy. Several reviewers had stated that when their cats played with this toy, they were full of energy, playing around and acting like a playful (but loopy) kitten again.
Of the construction, people like the attention to detail Yeowww! Put into making the banana? The logo was embroidered on, the stitching was secure, and the material was thick and durable.
Despite having glowing reviews by many customers, there were a few people who had some concerns. One of the main concerns people touched on was how strong the catnip scent is. Some said the banana they received wasn’t wrapped in anything, which caused other items shipped with the banana to have a strong catnip smell.
Also, some people said their cats played very aggressively with the banana and put some holes in the fabric, which caused the catnip to leak.
Alternative: Youngever 7 Cat Toys Assortment
Variety is the spice of life, and when it comes to keeping your kitty happy and hyped with catnip, the Youngever 7 Cat Toys Assortment won’t disappoint.
This assortment includes five refillable catnip fish toys, two squeaky mouse toys, and an extra packet of catnip so you can refill the toys when the catnip inside starts to lose its potency.
The size of these toys ranges from 7.5 inches to 8.6 inches, making them an excellent size for your cat to play with and even carry around.
The toys are made from a high-quality plush fabric that’s filled with cotton and 100% catnip. Also, there are zippers on the fish for easy refill. Notable Features of the Youngever 7 Cat Toys Assortment include:
Although these toys don’t have as many reviews as the other two products in this guide, most consumers felt that these were a great purchase. Customers liked that the fish had zippers to refill the catnip. Several people commented that their cats preferred the smaller fish toys over the larger ones, but they all got plenty of use.
With the good, you will always have some bad? Luckily there were only a small number of people who were disappointed with these toys. The majority of the concerns people had regarding these was that the catnip lost its potency quicker than expected.
Another concern people had was about the squeaky mice that were included. Folks pointed out that the mice were small, and the eyes, tail, and whiskers would come off the toy, thus making them a choking hazard for the cat.
What To Look For In The Best
When you’re looking to pick up the best catnip toys for cats, there are a few things you’ll want to take into consideration:
Safety And Durability
Cats have sharp teeth and claws, and when they’re around catnip, they can get pretty ferocious. Look for cat toys made from a durable fabric and tight stitching so that your cat doesn’t rip it apart in 2.5 seconds.
For safety, look to see if any small pieces could come off while your cat is playing with them. This can include things like tails, feathers, plastic eyes, and so forth.
Size And Shape
The size and shape of the toys you get for your cat are important because you don’t want to get them something that is so large, they can’t play with it, but also isn’t so small that your cat could choke on it.
Quality Catnip
When you’re looking for the best catnip toys, you should also consider the catnip’s quality inside the toys. We recommend only using 100% organic catnip because it will keep its potency longer, and you can give it to your cat without worrying about harmful chemicals.
Final Thoughts
All of the toys we mentioned here today are fantastic choices. We like that the SmartyKat and Youngever toys had a variety so your cat can pick and choose a favorite, but we also like that the Yeowww! Banana was made from a durable fabric, had tight stitching, and was filled with 100% catnip.
We think all of these deserve to be called the best catnip toys for cats, but the SmartyKat had better and more customer reviews than the other two options. It’s a tight race, but SmartyKat gets our stamp of approval!
